Lance Armstrong’s Dilemma
October 31st, 2012 at 5:30 pm
We love our heroes. We hate to see them fall, but when they do, they fall twice as hard. Lance Armstrong’s achievements as a cancer survivor, competitive athlete and fundraiser place him in a rare class of his own. Revelations that he (may have) cheated to win, and pressured his teammates to do the same, are disconcerting. Graced with remarkable talents, it feels tragic to us that he would succumb to a desire to win at any cost. Dilemmas abound in this case, for Lance Armstrong himself, for the professional cycling world and the bodies that oversee it, for the charitable organization founded by him to raise money to fight cancer, and finally, for fans who find themselves torn, not knowing whether to criticize him for such a moral lapse or stand by him for his courage, accomplishments and contributions. Let’s take a look at a few of these.
Part 1: How he got into this mess
Why do people cheat? Dan Ariely’s latest book, The Honest Truth About Dishonesty, explores the slippery slope of rationalization that renders lying and cheating acceptable. Hardly a rational process, lying is strongly influenced by social and psychological forces. If we are surrounded by cheaters, if we feel justified to lie, it becomes easier to do so. Step by rationalizing step, Armstrong slid into the lie. He is torn between the desire to advance his own interest and win versus respecting common rules and honoring fair play. Recovering from life-threatening testicular cancer, he may have needed a boost. Most survivors of aggressive cancer treatment feel lucky just to return to a normal daily routine, let alone push their bodies to compete with the world’s top athletes! Where is the clear line between therapeutic drugs and performance-enhancing drugs? Does his health condition justify bending the rules? How much artificial assistance is defensible, and what is the likelihood of detection?
Figure 1. © Transcend Strategy Group 2012
Armstrong is not the first and won’t be the last to feel the intense draw of temptation; from the corrupting power of the dark side of the Force in Star Wars to the mythic tale of Robert Johnson selling his soul in exchange for mastery over the guitar, we are all too familiar with the archetype of otherworldly ability-at-a-cost. What are some of the options Armstrong might have considered? Following the noble path of Selflessness (upper left quadrant), while admirable, is not an easy choice for fierce competitors, and clearly Armstrong is that! Shooting for the upper right box where Self Interest and Common Good intersect may be ideal, but perhaps not a real option here. The lower left quadrant, Foolishness, looks at first like a nonstarter, but a moment or two’s reflection shows that it happens all too often: remember Tiger Woods and Michael Vick? The final option, the one he appears to have chosen, is to do whatever it takes to win. Morality aside, outright pursuit of self-interest can be risky. Get caught, and the price you pay will be high. Armstrong got caught and is paying a hefty price for not managing this dilemma better.
Part 2: The outside-in perspective: cycling world and fans
How do we judge the choices and actions of others? Which is more important, intent or outcome; difficulty or result; style or substance? Is it ever OK to do bad things to achieve a greater good? Who decides when it is acceptable to reset conventional boundaries of right and wrong? If you could have killed Hitler in 1938 before the atrocities of the Holocaust occurred, would you have pulled the trigger? If you could hide the fact that you or someone else did something like this, would you, or is it more important that they be held accountable for the crime they committed? It took anti-doping agencies over a decade to finally render a stinging judgment against Armstrong, prompting a lifetime ban on any further competing and the retroactive loss of his seven Tour de France titles. Legal complexities and costs aside, this must have been a tough decision to take, given the predictable consequences to the man, the sport, the many fans, and the cancer cause for which his foundation has raised over $500 million.
Figure 2. © Transcend Strategy Group 2012
This matrix looks at the dilemma from the perspective of the leaders of the eponymous Lance Armstrong Foundation. On the one hand, they will want to stand by the founder and through solidarity, preserve the integrity and value of the organization and its capacity to do good (the horizontal axis). But on the other hand, as evidence against Armstrong mounts, credibility and survival depend upon facing reality, and seeing that truth and justice prevail (the vertical axis). Where will they end up? The best outcome they can hope for at this point is a graceful exit and transfer of leadership (upper right quadrant). They have started down this path. Armstrong stepped down as head of Livestrong on October 17th. Time will tell if the organization and Armstrong can successfully transition allowing the great fund-raising and awareness-raising work to continue.
Part 3: How he deals with the mess he’s in
Lance Armstrong has announced he will not challenge or fight the charges. The emotional, reputational and financial costs are punishing (Forbes estimates his earnings in 2010 from endorsements and speeches were in excess of $17 million). While appearing to accept the verdict, he rejects its accuracy, stubbornly maintaining his innocence. He has just tired of trying to prove it. The operators of the Tour de France are so convinced of his guilt that they have decided not to pass along the title to any of the other top competitors from the seven years in question. Doping, they say, was rampant in the sport during those years.
Figure 3. © Transcend Strategy Group 2012
How then should we depict Armstrong’s current dilemma? He has a great deal at stake, and at 41, many productive years ahead of him. We could look at money versus reputation, or, personal needs versus those of his charitable foundation. Globe and Mail reporter Hayley Mick has an interesting take on it (Armstrong’s dilemma: Fess up or shut up), looking at whether or not he admits to his guilt, when and how. In her article published on October 23, she follows the fates a number of other high profile figures caught in similarly embarrassing transgressions, some of whom were forgiven while others were not. Bill Clinton famously abused the power of his presidential office, then admitted his guilt through a very public and painful process, and in time returned to great popularity and prominence. He found Redemption. Baseball’s Barry Bonds and sprinter Ben Johnson both were found guilty of doping, both denied wrong-doing, and consequently, remain Pariahs who have not been forgiven. While Armstrong may be looking for a Graceful Exit, his refusal to take any responsibility for the mess he finds himself in is causing him to Lose Credibility, and become a Pariah to his charitable foundation and the sport he loves. Simply denying guilt doesn’t make it disappear. When you have been caught red-handed, it’s too late to cover up; you need to acknowledge the facts, take responsibility for your part in how things turned out, and swallow your lumps. Admitting guilt is not the opposite of protecting your reputation. It turns out it is the route you must follow if you want to recover it.
Send Comments to alex@transcendstrategy.com
Pingback: poor credit loan()
Pingback: Seo Day Seokanzler Wahlkampf()
Pingback: bad credit loans()
Pingback: Loan For Bad Credit()
Pingback: Loan For Bad Credit()
Pingback: stars acne()
Pingback: Loan For Bad Credit()
Pingback: Loans For People With Poor Credit()
Pingback: Loans For People With Poor Credit()
Pingback: click here()
Pingback: bad credit loans()
Pingback: Phentermine()
Pingback: poor credit lender()
Pingback: vimax pills()
Pingback: bad credit loans()
Pingback: I need air conditioner repairs Katy Tx cooling http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z0rQAm4ZL8E&feature=youtu.be()
Pingback: buy ambien online()
Pingback: Atlanta()
Pingback: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WgEO9nuf1kw()
Pingback: Boston Interior Design()
Pingback: New toys for Christmas()
Pingback: geschenkideen freundin 16()
Pingback: Top 10 Christmas toys()
Pingback: Leonie()
Pingback: youtube.com()
Pingback: Escort girls sex bulgaria escorts bg()
Pingback: navigate to these guys()
Pingback: transvaginal mesh lawsuit()
Pingback: Surrey SEO services()
Pingback: Forex Strategy Master, Forex Strategy Master discount, Forex Strategy Master review, Forex Strategy Master bonus()
Pingback: Pasadena texas()
Pingback: bail bonds york county()
Pingback: Power Lead Platform()
Pingback: DSLR 60D,Out of the Box: EOS digital slr 60 D Video Camera,EOS 60D of Canon Stardom()
Pingback: filipina girls()
Pingback: Greendell NJ()
Pingback: la bourse pour les nuls()
Pingback: Charlie()
Pingback: kitchen()
Pingback: Locksmith alexandria va │Locksmiths alexandria va │Residential Locksmith alexandria va │Commercial Locksmith alexandria va │ Auto Locksmith alexandria va │ Car Locksmith alexandria va │Unlock alexandria va │Unlock service alexandria va │Bu()
Pingback: massage trois-rivières()
Pingback: qwxgvnmkfbrvecganfhv()
Pingback: csevdhrbmkgnkjbhvdbjn()
Pingback: bgsvcvbhjfgmnbdvgbnhg()
Pingback: csngrdngthnfgdsfgnsfsd()
Pingback: gxcrcfgrtgsgabdjnhacfg()
Pingback: Computer recycling()
Pingback: recycle computers bracknell()
Pingback: Home Depot coupon()
Pingback: oakville()
Pingback: Million Hits Secret Review()
Pingback: computer recycling reading()
Pingback: best attorney in phoenix()
Pingback: IT Disposal bracknell()
Pingback: transfert k7 sur dvd()
Pingback: pay day loans online()
Pingback: Canada painters()
Pingback: News()
Pingback: set up business()
Pingback: dien dan chau van nha()
Pingback: dell latitude d630 battery()
Pingback: cheating boyfriend()
Pingback: auto insurance()
Pingback: Home()
Pingback: Como Perder A Barriga Rapido()
Pingback: top binary options broker()
Pingback: gclcmfgsjrmgdjsxmcg()
Pingback: Nuff Nang()
Pingback: shdkfhaskdghdskfhgksjdhfk()
Pingback: afsdfasdgfhdfgh()
Pingback: Buy World Cup Tickets Brazil()
Pingback: football table()
Pingback: commonwealth towers()
Pingback: Liverpool fc()
Pingback: como perder a barriga rapido()
Pingback: mobile casino()
Pingback: kampung inggris pare()
Pingback: buying twitter followers()
Pingback: Steam Punk Corsets()
Pingback: Cover Girl Chart()
Pingback: garcinia side effects()
Pingback: security systems()
Pingback: home security services reviews()
Pingback: vapor cig()
Pingback: Best Nightlife in Singapore()
Pingback: security systems for homes()
Pingback: royal wharf development()
Pingback: pirater un compte facebook()
Pingback: pirater un compte facebook()
Pingback: bwin indonesia()
Pingback: dich vu visa()
Pingback: pirater un compte facebook gratuit()
Pingback: barber schools in atlanta()
Pingback: pirater un compte facebook gratuit()
Pingback: carpet cleaning companies()
Pingback: bathroom remodeling houston()
Pingback: organic garcinia cambogia()
Pingback: busted tees coupon()
Pingback: motor club of america review()
Pingback: Wool Robe()
Pingback: Florida auto insurance()
Pingback: minecraft gratuit()
Pingback: naughty()
Pingback: aktoploika()
Pingback: Viio at Balestier()
Pingback: thl()
Pingback: biaya kampung inggris()
Pingback: battery compaq 6710s()
Pingback: Learn More()
Pingback: bigger penis without pills()
Pingback: Power()
Pingback: dien dan rao tin()
Pingback: Project()
Pingback: telefonsex()
Pingback: telefonsex()
Pingback: telefon sex()
Pingback: telefon sex()
Pingback: telefonsex()
Pingback: telefon sex()
Pingback: camsex()
Pingback: prolimehost()
Pingback: telefon sex()
Pingback: telefonsex()
Pingback: telefonsex handy()
Pingback: telefonsex()
Pingback: telefonsex livecam()
Pingback: telefonsex live()
Pingback: car rental()
Pingback: garcinia cambogia at gnc()
Pingback: denver divorce attorney()
Pingback: Studios()
Pingback: free annual credit report.com()
Pingback: How To Get Rid of Acne Scars()
Pingback: dubai job vacancies()
Pingback: Digital Marketing()
Pingback: Learn More()
Pingback: best forex signals()
Pingback: Hair Extensions Toronto()
Pingback: electronic cigarette vapor()
Pingback: Studios()
Pingback: mikroautobusu nuoma()
Pingback: Argos Furniture()
Pingback: transmission oil cooler()
Pingback: relationship tips for married & single couples()
Pingback: geile tiiten ficken()
Pingback: geile tiiten ficken()
Pingback: compare auto insurance quotes online()
Pingback: cheap insurance quotes comparison()
Pingback: assurance voiture sans permis()
Pingback: assurance voiture sans permis()
Pingback: bao nguoi viet()
Pingback: geile tiiten ficken()
Pingback: how to get rid of cold sores fast()
Pingback: geile tiiten ficken()
Pingback: Viagra To Your Door()
Pingback: geile tiiten ficken()
Pingback: yeast infection no more()
Pingback: Scarless breast surgery()
Pingback: assurance emprunteur()
Pingback: Classic Pasadena Homes()
Pingback: Fort Collins massage Therapy()
Pingback: adjustable kettlebell()
Pingback: http://www.livecareer.com()
Pingback: herbalife()
Pingback: payday loans()
Pingback: Pfandhaus Hamburg()
Pingback: forever 21 reviews()
Pingback: Home theathers conroe()
Pingback: garcinia cambogia weight loss reviews()
Pingback: Jim Easley()
Pingback: recipes()
Pingback: Deck builders conroe()
Pingback: bæresele()
Pingback: dr oz diet pill()
Pingback: green coffee beans pills()
Pingback: child porn()
Pingback: auto insurance quotes comparison()
Pingback: weight loss cleanse dr oz()
Pingback: child porn()
Pingback: attic remodeling conroe()
Pingback: casino()
Pingback: Mold inspection conroe()
Pingback: warez()
Pingback: tarjetas de plastico,()
Pingback: libertaddigital()
Pingback: tarjetas de plastico,()
Pingback: viagra online()
Pingback: bForex set-up()
Pingback: viagra online()
Pingback: bForex scam()
Pingback: tarjetas plasticas()
Pingback: tarjetas plasticas()
Pingback: viagra online()
Pingback: alex carter()
Pingback: Homeowner insurance quote()
Pingback: tarjetas plasticas()
Pingback: computer()
Pingback: rachat de credit()
Pingback: Fotografo de bodas en Zaragoza()
Pingback: read more()
Pingback: click here()
Pingback: viagra()
Pingback: gambling casinos()
Pingback: gambling casinos()
Pingback: aslan burcu()
Pingback: psle math()
Pingback: yengeç burcu()
Pingback: boost your bust download()
Pingback: CHIROPRACTIC WEBSITE TEMPLATE()
Pingback: Free Hack Tool Download()
Pingback: The Crest condo()
Pingback: psychic source reviews()
Pingback: buy traffic()
Pingback: best seo()
Pingback: dien dan rao vat viet nam()
Pingback: martial arts supplies()
Pingback: martial arts supplies()
Pingback: Payday Loans()
Pingback: hot training()
Pingback: Fifa 14 Ultimate team coins hack()
Pingback: jump manual exercises()
Pingback: capitulos de novela()
Pingback: Build Muscle()
Pingback: hot training()
Pingback: Learn french language easy free course()
Pingback: capitulos de novela()
Pingback: tarjetas plasticas()
Pingback: oxline quote car cheapest insurance rate()
Pingback: healthy snack ideas()
Pingback: tarjetas plasticas()
Pingback: News()
Pingback: alex carter()
Pingback: pregnancy miracle method()
Pingback: burçlar()
Pingback: slim diet pills()
Pingback: diatomaceous earth()
Pingback: diatomaceous earth()
Pingback: Nigger Rich()
Pingback: New Yorker Online Shop()
Pingback: New Yorker Online Shop()
Pingback: Construction()
Pingback: tarjetas de plastico()
Pingback: tarjetas de plastico()
Pingback: gullible fool()
Pingback: Life()
Pingback: tutorial 3Ds Max()
Pingback: tarjetas de plastico()
Pingback: tarjetas de plastico()
Pingback: cause of leg pain()
Pingback: gun blood()
Pingback: tarjetas de plastico()
Pingback: tarjetas de plastico()
Pingback: watch video()
Pingback: bookkeeping nz()
Pingback: mesothelioma()
Pingback: bookkeeping nz()