Leaving Oz On Rubio-Colored Slippers
March 21st, 2013 at 12:29 am
The Republicans face a dilemma and it’s a big one. During the 2012 election, Obama won over Hispanic voters by better than a 70-30 margin. Though Democrats always win the majority of Hispanic voters in national elections, this was quite a comedown for Republicans from the 44 percent of Hispanics who voted for Bush in the 2004 election. After the election, consensus quickly built among party insiders and strategists that without a plan to appeal to this growing demographic, Republicans would find the White House out of reach.
“We could have won this election if the party had a better brand name with Hispanics,” said Al Cardenas, chairman of the American Conservative Union, speaking to Nicolas Riccardi of the Associated Press. “I don’t believe there’s a path to the White House in the future that doesn’t include 38 percent-40 percent Hispanic support.”
Ideas have consequences, and this meme-that the White House would soon be beyond reach-quickly found its way into Republican orthodoxy. Immediately, the party began promoting its young immigrant and non-white stars, and Republican members of Congress turned nearly 180 degrees on the immigration issue. Senator Marco Rubio of Florida proposed a comprehensive immigration bill that accomplishes much of what Democrats have sought for a decade, and he did it without much pushback from the party. It’s astonishing really, since in the spring of 2012, most of the primary candidates for the Republican nomination tried to outdo each other in how tough they could be on restricting a path to immigration, particularly for undocumented Hispanics. Rick Perry’s campaign really came apart after he told the other candidates “they didn’t have a heart” on issues related to undocumented Mexican immigrants!
Heads They Win, Tails We Lose
But coming around to reality on immigration doesn’t solve the party’s electoral woes. It’s just the start of a long and overdue rebuilding process. As a recent cartoon by the Washington Post’s Tom Toles illustrates, Republican’s lose either way in the immigration debate. [Ed. The cartoon shows a donkey and an elephant discussing an immigration bil. The donkey says “If you don’t sign, you’ll lose votes.” And, the elephant responds “If I do sign, you’ll gain votes.” ] If Republicans don’t sign a bill they lose Hispanic votes in the next election. If they do agree to allow more immigrants into the US and naturalize some of those who have resided here illegally, they may still lose because newer immigrants tend to vote Democratic.
Given all of this, what is the right strategy for the Republican party – hang in with traditional positions and values? Soften on this set of issues to “buy” Hispanic votes? Promise changes in return for support (i.e., sell the future to win the present)? The correct answer of course is none of the above. US democracy depends on there being two party options available. By available we mean able to win and capable of governing. This takes issue-leadership and broad appeal. Both parties need to be able to represent the needs of the vast majority of the country’s citizens. Rehabilitating credibility and capacity is needed – it’s overdue. This is substantial, long-term work, not a set of cosmetic touch-ups packaged and positioned by marketers. The right strategy for the party is one that respects and leverages core Republican values while simultaneously re-establishing itself as modern and open to today’s young people and immigrants. That won’t be done overnight.
The Installed Base Problem
One concept we can borrow to examine the Republican dilemma comes from the world of technology: the installed base. An installed base is the set of individuals who have adopted your product. Many products exhibit “network effects” i.e, the product becomes more valuable as more people use it. Political parties exhibit a form of this that market researchers call “social effects”: adoption by others updates or validates your self-image or opinion, and increases your social utility. In short, as a political party becomes stronger—has a larger installed base—a positive feedback loop is created. It becomes easier to pass legislation and more voters may want to identify with that party. But in technology there is a down side to having a huge installed base – with growth comes resistance to change, as long-time users become accustomed to the status quo and reject efforts to improve or update features, creating an opening for competitors.
A highly inflexible installed base hampers a political party’s ability to make timely policy changes. Before long, strength becomes weakness, and the same things that lock in a loyal core, lock out a growing majority of voters. Republicans have a strong, installed base who historically have been opposed to social changes from women’s liberation to liberalized immigration policies to gay marriage. But, like Microsoft in the ’90s when the company had to satisfy both legacy DOS users and those who wanted a faster modernization of Windows, Republicans need to hold onto current voters while reaching out to new ones. They are already taking the first tentative steps down that road, recognizing that there is no inherent conflict between Republican tenets and openness to the latest generation of immigrants. But any significant influx of new Hispanic voters will probably help Democrats in the short term.
The strategic necessity to change the party’s position on immigration becomes clear when you plot the relationship between possible legislative outcomes against changes in the historic Republican position (see diagram). If the Republicans take a hard-line position against immigration reform, they are handing elections for the foreseeable future to the Democrats, with very little prospect for gains, regardless of what happens with new immigration legislation. Ironically, the impact on the party’s fortunes appear worse if they succeed in scuttling legislation, which now appears unlikely (lower left). Only if they make the position change now can they set themselves up to gain a larger share of immigrant votes in future elections and contribute to a sense of national unity on this key issue.
Pingback: horse betting systems()
Pingback: loans for really bad credit()
Pingback: loan for people with bad credit()
Pingback: What is mannatech()
Pingback: Phentermine()
Pingback: bad credit loans()
Pingback: loans with poor credit()
Pingback: Cigarette electronique()
Pingback: empower network()
Pingback: bad credit loans()
Pingback: I need air conditioner repair Sugar Land air conditoner http://youtube.com/watch?v=Z0rQAm4ZL8E&feature=youtu.be()
Pingback: buy ambien online()
Pingback: Interior Designer()
Pingback: Video ansehen()
Pingback: Best toy for Christmas()
Pingback: toys for Christmas 2013()
Pingback: cigarette electronique()
Pingback: tube cash code review()
Pingback: Escort girls sex bulgaria escorts bg()
Pingback: Annika()
Pingback: hyper 9x()
Pingback: wie kann man schnell abnehmem()
Pingback: http://listofdomains.org/alexa/Alexa_105.html()
Pingback: provillus for hair loss()
Pingback: Forex Strategy Master, Forex Strategy Master discount, Forex Strategy Master review, Forex Strategy Master bonus()
Pingback: The best Miami yacht brokers can be found at www.miamiyachts.org()
Pingback: this content()
Pingback: bail bonds york county()
Pingback: youtu.be/-Qbcu45p7rw()
Pingback: viriadian energy()
Pingback: clip in hair extensions for thin hair()
Pingback: primerica jobs()
Pingback: Mykonos Island()
Pingback: watch hentai()
Pingback: rinoplasty utah()
Pingback: la bourse pour les nuls()
Pingback: Lose Fat()
Pingback: seo wilmington nc()
Pingback: Locksmith alexandria va │Locksmiths alexandria va │Residential Locksmith alexandria va │Commercial Locksmith alexandria va │ Auto Locksmith alexandria va │ Car Locksmith alexandria va │Unlock alexandria va │Unlock service alexandria va │Bu()
Pingback: Locksmith alexandria va │Locksmiths alexandria va │Residential Locksmith alexandria va │Commercial Locksmith alexandria va │ Auto Locksmith alexandria va │ Car Locksmith alexandria va │Unlock alexandria va │Unlock service alexandria va │Bu()
Pingback: Look At This()
Pingback: french bulldog puppies()
Pingback: Mobile Alabama Riding Lawn Mowwer Repairs()
Pingback: does text your ex back work()
Pingback: cigarette electronique()
Pingback: axmcsnrcaxmgcnacgnr()
Pingback: csmrynkmgfgktjglsrtmsgxn()
Pingback: gxcrcfgrtgsgabdjnhacfg()
Pingback: pc disposal bracknell()
Pingback: painters in your area()
Pingback: num�risation de cassettes()
Pingback: pc disposal maidenhead()
Pingback: IT Recycling berkshire()
Pingback: pay day loans direct lenders()
Pingback: Divorce Lawyer in Phoenix()
Pingback: Zappos Coupons()
Pingback: Corporate Computer Recycling berkshire()
Pingback: Million Hits Secret()
Pingback: best Toronto painters()
Pingback: food tasting sessions()
Pingback: how to catch a cheating boyfriend()
Pingback: dell studio 1558 battery()
Pingback: forex introducing broker()
Pingback: dien dan mua ban backlink()
Pingback: Improvement()
Pingback: auto insurance()
Pingback: gclcmfgsjrmgdjsxmcg()
Pingback: Finance()
Pingback: shdkfhaskdghdskfhgksjdhfk()
Pingback: Exercicios Para Perder A Barriga Rapido()
Pingback: lucrative home business()
Pingback: sports tickets. Liverpool fixtures()
Pingback: football table()
Pingback: commonwealth towers floor plan()
Pingback: afsdfasdgfhdfgh()
Pingback: FIFA World Cup Tickets()
Pingback: Cover Girl Chart()
Pingback: pendaftaran kampung inggris()
Pingback: slots()
Pingback: True Waist Training Corsets()
Pingback: gain twitter followers()
Pingback: como perder a barriga rapido()
Pingback: Top Bars in Singapore()
Pingback: options trading education()
Pingback: home security alarms reviews()
Pingback: Future Of Wealth Review Anik()
Pingback: vapor cigarettes review()
Pingback: garcinia cambogia extract side effects()
Pingback: video surveillance for home()
Pingback: carpet cleaning()
Pingback: pirater un compte facebook gratuit()
Pingback: pirater un compte facebook()
Pingback: pirater un compte facebook gratuit()
Pingback: royal wharf oxley()
Pingback: dich vu tang referring domain()
Pingback: Smoking Robe()
Pingback: natural garcinia cambogia extract()
Pingback: Chegg Coupon()
Pingback: minecraft gratuit()
Pingback: aktoploika()
Pingback: backpage()
Pingback: kampung inggris di kediri()
Pingback: bigger penis without pills()
Pingback: dewalt battery dc9096()
Pingback: thl phone()
Pingback: Learn More()
Pingback: battery compaq 6715s()
Pingback: dien dan rao vat tong hop()
Pingback: london()
Pingback: telefonsex()
Pingback: telefon sex()
Pingback: prolimehost()
Pingback: telefonsex()
Pingback: camsex()
Pingback: telefon sex()
Pingback: telefon sex()
Pingback: telefonsex mit bild()
Pingback: telefon sex()
Pingback: livecam telefonsex()
Pingback: camsex()
Pingback: telefonsex()
Pingback: telefon sex()
Pingback: camsex()
Pingback: divorce attorney denver colorado()
Pingback: can u buy garcinia cambogia at gnc()
Pingback: Learn More()
Pingback: Social Media Agency()
Pingback: Hair Extensions Toronto()
Pingback: How To Get Rid of Acne Fast()
Pingback: cedar finance trading()
Pingback: vapor liquid()
Pingback: cheap web traffic()
Pingback: Argos UK()
Pingback: mikroautobusu nuoma()
Pingback: Movie()
Pingback: automatic transmission filter()
Pingback: autobusu nuoma()
Pingback: parenting issues & problems()
Pingback: cheap car insurance instant quote()
Pingback: Car insurance quote comparison()
Pingback: geile tiiten ficken()
Pingback: geile tiiten ficken()
Pingback: geile tiiten ficken()
Pingback: geile tiiten ficken()
Pingback: assurance voiture sans permis()
Pingback: assurance voiture sans permis()
Pingback: geile tiiten ficken()
Pingback: inforegistry()
Pingback: how to get rid of cold sore fast()
Pingback: real estate agent in Pasadena()
Pingback: bao nhan dan()
Pingback: adjustable kettlebell()
Pingback: massage in fort collins()
Pingback: assurance emprunteur()
Pingback: adjustable kettlebell()
Pingback: Get Free Bitcoins()
Pingback: http://www.livecareer.com()
Pingback: herbalife()
Pingback: herbalife()
Pingback: Mold inspection conroe()
Pingback: Deck builders conroe()
Pingback: green coffee bean extract pills()
Pingback: dr oz weight loss fruit()
Pingback: recipes()
Pingback: attic remodeling conroe()
Pingback: Autoquote()
Pingback: forever 21 reviews()
Pingback: Home theathers conroe()
Pingback: forever 21 reviews()
Pingback: Water restoration conroe()
Pingback: ergobaby()
Pingback: Pfandleihhaus Hamburg()
Pingback: child porn()
Pingback: casino()
Pingback: tarjetas de plastico,()
Pingback: weight loss on dr oz()
Pingback: warez()
Pingback: casino()
Pingback: can garcinia cambogia cause weight gain()
Pingback: libertaddigital()
Pingback: Best cheapest homeowners insurance()
Pingback: New Jersey online casinos()
Pingback: Does make him desire you work()
Pingback: viagra online()
Pingback: bForex company()
Pingback: bForex set-up()
Pingback: make your own beats()
Pingback: viagra online()
Pingback: bForex scam()
Pingback: garcinia cambogia extract benefits()
Pingback: tarjetas plasticas()
Pingback: viagra online()
Pingback: tarjetas plasticas()
Pingback: http://www.gmhts.com()
Pingback: tarjetas plasticas()
Pingback: Kamagra()
Pingback: Kamagra()
Pingback: bail bonds()
Pingback: rachat de credit()
Pingback: tarjetas plasticas()
Pingback: Fotografo de bodas en Zaragoza()
Pingback: computer()
Pingback: website()
Pingback: homepage()
Pingback: viagra()
Pingback: gambling casinos()
Pingback: gambling casinos()
Pingback: psychic source review()
Pingback: seo powersuite()
Pingback: buy traffic()
Pingback: boost your bust book()
Pingback: YouTube()
Pingback: buy traffic()
Pingback: psle singapore()
Pingback: Download Hacks()
Pingback: rao vat()
Pingback: CHIROPRACTIC WEBSITE DESIGNS()
Pingback: jiu jitsu gi()
Pingback: martial arts supplies()
Pingback: Payday Loans()
Pingback: purificadoras de agua()
Pingback: purificadoras de agua()
Pingback: capitulos de novela()
Pingback: affordable auto insurance quote()
Pingback: Learn french language easy free course()
Pingback: healthy snack ideas()
Pingback: jump manual()
Pingback: capitulos de novela()
Pingback: tarjetas plasticas()
Pingback: make him desire you program()
Pingback: burçlar()
Pingback: Fifa 14 Coin Generator 2014()
Pingback: Information()
Pingback: tarjetas plasticas()
Pingback: pregnancy diet()
Pingback: anabolic cooking()
Pingback: diatomaceous earth()
Pingback: diatomaceous earth()
Pingback: Movie()
Pingback: Punk Ass Bitch()
Pingback: New Yorker Online Shop()
Pingback: New Yorker Online Shop()
Pingback: tarjetas de plastico()
Pingback: Business()
Pingback: tarjetas de plastico()
Pingback: tutorial civilcad()
Pingback: back pain alternative medicine()
Pingback: Collecting()
Pingback: gullible fool()
Pingback: tarjetas de plastico()
Pingback: tarjetas de plastico()
Pingback: tarjetas de plastico()
Pingback: tarjetas de plastico()
Pingback: tarjetas de plastico.()
Pingback: mesothelioma()
Pingback: check this out()
Pingback: viagra auckland()
Pingback: read more()